Indonesia Faces Potential MSCI Downgrade to Standalone Market Status
On October 15, MSCI launched a consultation on reclassifying Indonesia from Emerging Market to Standalone Market status, skipping the intermediate Frontier tier. MSCI acknowledged reforms announced by Indonesian authorities, including disclosure of shareholders above 1%, reporting on high shareholding concentration, and a roadmap to a 15% minimum free float. However, it said market participants had not seen consistent progress, citing continued suspected coordinated trading and a lack of meaningful enforcement. MSCI will accept feedback until April 30, 2027, and announce its decision by June 30, 2027. It expects to proceed unless the consultation shows clear evidence of material improvement in market governance.
Markets reacted sharply. The Jakarta Composite Index fell 11.6% on October 16, its steepest one-day drop in nearly three decades, after Indonesia’s weight in the MSCI Emerging Markets Index had already fallen from 1.16% to 0.43% this year. Goldman Sachs estimates that full removal could trigger US$5.6 billion in passive outflows on top of US$4.88 billion in net foreign selling so far this year. The Financial Services Authority (OJK) said it respects MSCI’s view and will strengthen enforcement. Members with Indonesian exposure can find more information and submit feedback to MSCI here.
Indonesian authorities have since stepped up enforcement. On October 21, OJK handed down its largest-ever fines, totaling IDR 2.1 trillion (US$117 million), over trading violations in the shares of three listed companies. On October 26, the Indonesian Stock Exchange (IDX) announced that it will investigate suspected coordinated trading and freeze suspicious investor accounts, rather than only issuing warnings. It will also add independent members, including academics and a foreign investor representative, to the committee that identifies high-concentration stocks. MSCI has said it wants evidence of sustained enforcement across the whole market, beyond index constituents and the largest securities.